The two sides of the ECS coin
11/07/2019

The concept of ‘electronic communications service’ (“ECS”) defined in Article 2(c) of Directive 2002/21/EC (“Framework Directive”) has been interpreted in two decisions of the ECJ in June 2019: C‑142/18 Skype communications and C-193/18 Google LLC.

To be an ECS or not to be

In simple terms, the Court had to decide whether Gmail and SkypeOut respectively consist “wholly or mainly in the conveyance of signals” as required by Article 2(c) of the Framework Directive in order to qualify as ECS.

On the one hand, SkypeOut is a Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) service that, in return for remuneration, allows its users to call a fixed or mobile number covered by a national numbering plan from a terminal (e.g. computer, phone, tablet) via the public switched telephone network (PSTN). In order to provide this service, Skype Communications relies on the contribution of Internet Service Providers (“ISP”) and telecommunications service providers for the transmission of signals. On the other hand, Gmail is a web-based email service, which enables its users to transfer data and emails over the internet. Google does not itself provide access to Internet, nor does it transfer the data and emails over the internet. The ECJ considered it insufficient to qualify as ECS that Google assigns the IP addresses and uploads the data packets (i.e. the data and emails that are broken down by Google) to the open internet and receives them from the internet.

As to the qualification of SlypeOut as ECS, the Court stated that Skypeout consists principally in transmitting voice signals. The Court, although acknowledging that Skype is not involved at the technical level, considers that Skype is noneless responsible towards its users for the signals conveyance mainly in view of the agreements concluded between Skype and the telecommunications service providers for the signal transmission to the national mobile or fixed connection point of the user receiving the call.  

Impact of the decision

The question arises as to whether these two rulings will still matter after entry into force of Directive 2018/1972 (“EECC”), which broadens the concept of ECS so as to also include interpersonal communications services (“ICS”) which should encapsulate emails and VoIP services.

The answer is yes, it does matter. Firstly, the EECC must be transposed by 21 December 2020, so that in the meantime, the current rules on electronic communications networks and services will still apply, including their interpretation by the ECJ. Secondly, the qualification as ECS triggers the applicability of several national and international/European legal requirements (such as emergency calling, cooperation with authorities, privacy and security obligations), but also has influences on the ECS’s users, subscribers and even law enforcement authorities. Lastly, the ECS definition under the EECC still includes the conveyance of signals as a criterion; besides, certain rules of the EECC only apply to ICS, e.g. information requirement for contracts, quality of services, transparency, publication of information, etc. Henceforth, it is relevant to understand whether a service qualifies as ECS because it consists in the conveyance of signals, or alternatively, because it is an ICS.

 

Cyril Fischer
cyril.fischer@stibbe.com

Zie ook : Stibbe


Click here to see the ad(s)
Alle artikels Telecommunicatierecht

Laatste artikels Telecommunicatierecht

Caméras de vidéosurveillance : la date limite du 25 mai approche !
22/05/2020

La « loi caméras » réglemente l’usage de la vidéosurveillance afin d&rsqu...

Caméras de vidéosurveillance : la date limite du 25 mai approche ! Read more

Deadline approaching for notifying CCTV cameras to Belgian police
15/05/2020

The transition period for notifying your surveillance closed-circuit television cameras (“CCTV cameras”) to th...

Deadline approaching for notifying CCTV cameras to Belgian police Read more

Connected Vehicles and GDPR – A Status Update after the Public Consultation
14/05/2020

Many vehicles that were launched in the last few years contain sensors, cameras, a GPS and other data capturing technologi...

Read more

Autonomous Vehicles in Belgium. Is our legal system ready?
27/04/2020

We have been hearing about autonomous vehicles (“AVs”) for quite a while. However, as time goes by, the use of...

Autonomous Vehicles in Belgium. Is our legal system ready? Read more

LexGO Network