The taste of cheese cannot be protected by copyright! What about fragrances of perfume?
22/11/2018

The Court of justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) ruled on 13 November 2018 in the case C-310/17 that the taste of cheese is not a “work” in the meaning of the Directive 2001/29/EC on copyrights (“Directive”) and can therefore not be protected by copyright.

Although the CJEU did not rule on the smell of the cheese concerned, this decision will undoubtedly have an impact on the question of protection of fragrances by copyright and may lead to a more harmonised case law throughout Europe. Read more...

1. Background 

The “Heksenkaas” created in 2007 by Levola Hengelo BV (“Levola”), a company under Dutch law, is a spreadable dip with cream cheese.

Smilde Foods BV (“Smilde”), another company under Dutch law, has been manufacturing a product called “Witte Wievenkaas” since January 2014 for the Aldi supermarkets in the Netherlands.

Levola considered that the production and sale of ‘Witte Wievenkaas’ infringed its copyright in the taste of Heksenkaas. Hence, Lovela decided to bring legal action against Smilde due to this infringement.

Levola’s complaint was initially dismissed by the Dutch Gelderland District Court, on the grounds that the taste of Heksenkaas lacked originality and personal character.

Levola appealed this decision and the Dutch Appeals Court referred several questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling on the interpretation of the concept of a “work” under the Directive and whether it includes the taste of a food product.

2. Answer of the Court

In its judgment of 13 November 2018, the CJEU indicated that, in order to be protected by copyright under the Directive, the taste of a food product must be capable of being classified as a “work”.

-  What does “work” mean under the Directive?

A “work” must meet the following requirements:

it must be original, in the sense that it is the author’s own intellectual creation;
it must be expressed in a manner which makes it identifiable with sufficient precision and objectivity.

Copyright protection may be granted to expressions, but not to ideas, procedures, and methods of operation or mathematical concepts as such, as they need to be expressed in some sort of medium.

-  Can a cheese taste be considered as a “work”?

The taste of a cheese does not meet the form-of-expression requirement since it lacks precision and objectivity because it depends on the consumer’s sense of taste, which is subjective and variable. Indeed, it will depend on factors particular to the consumer, such as age, food preferences and consumption habits.

In addition, the current state of the art does not enable the taste of a product such as cheese to be identified precisely and to be distinguished from the taste of other products.

3. Impact of the decision limited to the food industry?

The taste of a food product can therefore not be considered as a “work” and consequently it cannot be protected by copyright under the Directive.

This decision will undoubtedly have an impact on the question of the protection of fragrances by copyright and may lead to a more harmonised case law in the matter.

In fact, the Supreme Courts in France and in the Netherlands currently have opposed views on the matter.

But the CJEU has not definitely closed the matter as it admits that, if the subject matter protected by copyright must be expressed in a manner which makes it identifiable with sufficient precision and objectivity, that expression is not necessarily in a permanent form. In addition, it recognises that its conclusion depends of the current state of scientific development and, as a consequence, one cannot exclude that the latter will achieve by technical means a precise and objective identification of the taste or smell of the product in question which enables it to be distinguished from the taste or smell of other products of the same kind.

Thus, to be followed....

Related : Lydian ( Mrs. Annick Mottet Haugaard ,  Ms. Olivia Santantonio ,  Ms. Blandine de Lange )

[+ http://www.lydian.be]

Mrs. Annick Mottet Haugaard Mrs. Annick Mottet Haugaard
Partner
annick.mottet@lydian.be
Ms. Olivia Santantonio Ms. Olivia Santantonio
Counsel
olivia.santantonio@lydian.be
Ms. Blandine de Lange Ms. Blandine de Lange
Associate
blandine.delange@lydian.be

Click here to see the ad(s)
All articles Intellectual property law

Lastest articles Intellectual property law

COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 19 May
19/05/2020

The COVID-19 pandemic is progressing worldwide. In an effort to control its expansion, public authorities have taken restr...

COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 19 May Read more

COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 12 May
13/05/2020

Update 12 May 2020  |  The COVID-19 pandemic is progressing worldwide. In an effort to control its expansio...

COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 12 May Read more

Legislative initiatives on compulsory licensing in light of Covid-19
08/05/2020

With more than 50 clinical trials underway for covid-19 related therapies, the question as to how and at what price such t...

Read more

COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 5 May
06/05/2020

Update 5 May 2020  |  The COVID-19 pandemic is progressing worldwide. In an effort to control its expansion...

 COVID-19 – IP Offices take measures to face the pandemic – Update 5 May Read more

Lastest articles by Mrs. Annick Mottet Haugaard

Always look on the bright side of life”: Which remuneration is due to the artists when playing ...
18/04/2020

In these difficult times, where live music performance and events are postponed or cancelled, the economic situation of ar...

Read more

Toegang tot justitie in tijden van Corona
16/04/2020

Nu de semi-lockdown al een maand in voege is, begint meer en meer duidelijk te worden dat de door de overheid opgelegde re...

Read more

What could stop the on-line sales of illegal goods in times of COVID-19? Certainly not the ECJ de...
10/04/2020

In its decision of 2 April 2020 in the case C-567/18, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) held that Amazon is not leg...

Read more

To what extent can artists use trademarks in their works?
15/11/2019

The Benelux Court of Justice (“BCJ”), an international court composed of magistrates from the highest courts o...

Read more

Lastest articles by Ms. Olivia Santantonio

Connected Vehicles and GDPR – A Status Update after the Public Consultation
14/05/2020

Many vehicles that were launched in the last few years contain sensors, cameras, a GPS and other data capturing technologi...

Read more

Always look on the bright side of life”: Which remuneration is due to the artists when playing ...
18/04/2020

In these difficult times, where live music performance and events are postponed or cancelled, the economic situation of ar...

Read more

What could stop the on-line sales of illegal goods in times of COVID-19? Certainly not the ECJ de...
10/04/2020

In its decision of 2 April 2020 in the case C-567/18, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) held that Amazon is not leg...

Read more

To what extent can artists use trademarks in their works?
15/11/2019

The Benelux Court of Justice (“BCJ”), an international court composed of magistrates from the highest courts o...

Read more

Lastest articles by Ms. Blandine de Lange

Implementation of EU Directive No 2015/2436 relating to trademarks into Benelux legislation: wha...
13/12/2018

The EU Directive No 2015/2436 (Directive), one of the pillars of the trademark law reform at the European level, must be t...

Read more

The European Court of Justice further clarifies the notion of ‘communication to the public’ r...
19/05/2017

In its ruling of 26 April 2017 (C-527/15), the European Court of Justice (hereafter, the ECJ) has further clarif...

Read more

GDPR: WP29 Issues Guidance on Data Portability
30/12/2016

Article 20 of the GDPR creates a new right to data portability. This allows for data subjects to receive the personal data...

Read more

Repackaging: when is it allowed?
12/12/2016

On 10 November 2016, the European Union Court of Justice (ECJ) rendered a judgment regarding the "need of repackaging...

Read more

LexGO Network