Judicial reorganization – Accounting review – Annexes to the petition


In order to secure the protection of judicial reorganization, the debtor needs to attach to the petition for judicial reorganization a certain number of documents provided for in article 17 § 2 of the Law on the continuity of enterprises (LCE). If these documents are not attached to the petition, the LCE provides that the petition shall be deemed inadmissible.

These documents include "a balance sheet and profit and loss statement dating back no more than three months". The law of 27 May 2013 amended this article by making the intervention of an auditor or certified accountant mandatory. The remit of such a professional involves limited control and an analytical review of the accounting situation. The aim of this control and review is to assure affected third parties that the financial data does not show any significant inconsistency and/or obvious overvaluation. The professional accountant therefore needs to examine to a limited extent whether the accounting situation reflects the facts.

Court and tribunal applications

Recently, in November 2014, the Mons Court of Appeal judged inadmissible the demand to obtain the opening of judicial reorganization proceedings because the auditor's report did not, according to the Court, comply with article 17 of the LCE].

According to the Court of Appeal, if the auditor or the certified accountant does not need to perform a full scope audit and certify the accounts and forecasts of the debtor, they should, nevertheless, exercise limited control and not just take note of the data given by the debtor.

In casu, the auditor's report clearly stated that the assistance and supervision of the auditor in the accounting situation of the company facing financial difficulties could not be considered as control.

The Court considered that even if it's legitimate for the auditor to express reservation in regard to the extent of his intervention, nevertheless it is the auditor's duty to exercise limited control of the accounting situation and to give his advice on whether or not the forecasts can be deemed reasonable.

Concretely, the reviews of the auditors and certified accountants need to specify, on the one hand, that there is no significant inconsistency in the accounting results in question or obvious overvaluation of the net assets, and, on the other hand, that the forecasts are reasonable. If these points are not expressly mentioned in the review, the review should at least not contain any contrary claims.

In conclusion, particular attention should therefore be paid to the form of the auditors' and certified accountants' reviews.


Related : CMS Belgium ( Mr. Grégory De Sauvage ,  Mr. Jean-François Goffin ,  Ms. Madeleine Brouhns )

[+ http://newsletter.cms-db.info/article.asp?nid=950c4761e0ce26395c319950de90f0d1&did=11&aid=4102&y=2015&m=3]

Mr. Grégory De Sauvage Mr. Grégory De Sauvage
Senior Associate
Mr. Jean-François Goffin Mr. Jean-François Goffin
Ms. Madeleine Brouhns Ms. Madeleine Brouhns

Click here to see the ad(s)
All articles Accounting law

Lastest articles Accounting law

Toekennen van tantièmes aan gewezen bestuurders

Een vennootschap kan naar aanleiding van de winstverdeling van het boekjaar een deel van haar winst uitkeren aan haar bedr...

Toekennen van tantièmes aan gewezen bestuurders Read more

Coordination de certaines règles comptables

Le législateur a réuni dans un seul arrêté royal les règles relatives &ag...

Read more

La réforme de l’audit pour la Saint Sylvestre

Le 31 décembre 2016, la réforme de l’audit fera son entrée dans le paysage juridique belge...

Read more

Modifications for companies' annual accounts as of financial year 2016

The requirements regarding the form, content and filing of companies' annual accounts have changed for the financial y...

Modifications for companies' annual accounts as of financial year 2016 Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Grégory De Sauvage

Bankruptcy of the debtor: not all is necessarily lost

The unpaid creditors of a company which has been declared bankrupt after running through a procedure of judicial reorganiz...

Read more

Late payments to the tax authority – directors be careful

A recent case reminds us of the fact that, since 2006, the Belgian tax authority has wielded a frightening weapon against ...

Read more

Moving towards a decrease in the number of bankruptcies, thanks to accountants?

Accountants will from now on play an important role in both the identification of companies facing difficulties and in the...

Read more

The success of the law on the continuity of undertakings leads to a reform

A bill modifying various legislation regarding the continuity of undertakings was adopted by the House of Representatives ...

Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Jean-François Goffin

The obligation of convocation of a general meeting

The convocation of an extraordinary general meeting by the directors of a company is compulsory and legally enforceable wh...

Read more

Lastest articles by Ms. Madeleine Brouhns

LexGO Network