CJEU doesn't like the taste of copyright
14/11/2018

Today, the Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") decided that the taste of a food product is not eligible for copyright protection. The question was raised in a dispute concerning the spreadable Dutch cheese known as "Heksenkaas" ("witch cheese") and the CJEU's answer can be found here. In a nutshell, the CJEU rules that the taste of a food product does not qualify as a work because, in short, it cannot be pinned down with precision and objectivity.


Background
The dispute leading up to this CJEU decision revolves around two spreadable dips containing cream cheese and fresh herbs: "Heksenkaas" on the one hand and "Witte Wievenkaas" on the other hand. The manufacturer of Heksenkaas, Levola Hengelo B.V. ("Levola"), took the position that the taste of this food product is protected by copyright and that Smilde Foods B.V. ("Smilde") infringes this copyright with the production and sale of the "Witte Wievenkaas" food product. Smilde however alleged that a taste in itself cannot be protected by copyright. The Court of Appeal of Arnhem-Leeuwarden sought a preliminary ruling by the CJEU to end the ongoing debate (see also our eNewsletter of 27 June 2017) on the possibility of copyright protection of a specific taste.


CJEU Decision
In the present judgment, the CJEU rules that the taste of a food product cannot be protected by copyright as it is not a work within the meaning of the Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC).

In order to qualify as a "work", there are two cumulative conditions that must be met: the subject matter needs to be (i) original in that it is the author's own intellectual creation and (ii) the expression of that creation. With reference to the Berne Convention, the WIPO Copyright Treaty and the TRIPs Agreement, the CJEU further explains that protection may be granted to expressions but not to ideas, procedures, methods of operation or mathematical concepts. The CJEU then goes on to state that the subject matter protected by copyright only qualifies as a work if it is expressed "in a manner which makes it identifiable with sufficient precision and objectivity, even though that expression is not necessarily in a permanent form" (para. 40).

The CJEU however finds that the taste of a food product cannot be "pinned down with precision and objectivity". Rather, "the taste of a food product will be identified essentially on the basis of taste sensations and experiences, which are subjective and variable since they depend, inter alia, on factors particular to the person tasting the product concerned, such as age, food preferences and consumption habits, as well as on the environment or context in which the product is consumed" (para. 42). The CJEU also points out that "currently" it is not technically possible to identify, in a precise and objective manner, the taste of a food product and distinguish it from the taste of other products of the same kind.

Comments
With this judgment the CJEU followed the opinion of the advocate general, as was generally expected. The legal certainty rationale underlying the decision is furthermore understandable: in order to rely on copyright protection, one must be able to identify the subject matter in a precise and objective way. Not all seems lost though: it will be interesting to see whether copyright protection for taste will perhaps be possible in the future upon advancement of the "state of scientific development to achieve by technical means a precise and objective identification of the taste of a food product" (para. 43)!

Voir aussi : NautaDutilh ( Mr. Tanguy de Haan )

[+ http://www.nautadutilh.com]


Click here to see the ad(s)
Tous les articles Droit Européen

Derniers articles Droit Européen

Belgium introduces plain packaging for tobacco products
15/07/2019

Following the example of Australia, the UK, Norway and France, Belgium has introduced plain packaging for tobacco products...

Belgium introduces plain packaging for tobacco products Read more

Nieuw fiscaal regime in Italië richt zich op gepensioneerde buitenlanders
15/07/2019

“La dolce vita” in Italië, het kan sinds 1 januari 2019 ook voor gepensioneerden zonder extreme vermogens...

Nieuw fiscaal regime in Italië richt zich op gepensioneerde buitenlanders Read more

EU Regulation on online platforms approved
26/06/2019

On 14 June 2019, the Council of the European Union approved the new Regulation on promoting fairness and transparency of o...

EU Regulation on online platforms approved Read more

Plain Cigarette Packaging in Belgium as from 1st January 2020
24/06/2019

Plain packaging is gaining ground in Europe and around the world. Following in the footsteps of France, the United Kingdom...

Read more

Derniers articles de Mr. Tanguy de Haan

Plain Cigarette Packaging in Belgium as from 1st January 2020
24/06/2019

Plain packaging is gaining ground in Europe and around the world. Following in the footsteps of France, the United Kingdom...

Read more

New Protection for Trade Secrets
26/09/2018

On 14 August, the Act of 30 July 2018 on the protection of trade secrets was published in the Belgian State Gazette, final...

Read more

Debranding Before Import Not Allowed
06/08/2018

The CJEU sided with Mitsubishi and ruled that a trade mark proprietor has the right to oppose the removal by third parties...

Read more

EU Trade Marks Should Be Distinctive Throughout the EU, Not Just a Significant Part Thereof
01/08/2018

In its recent Nestlé v Mondelez decision (C-84/17P, C-85/17P and C-95/17P), the Court of Justice of the European Un...

Read more

LexGO Network