Antitrust: A Commitment Decision is a Prima Facie Evidence of an Infringement, for the ECJ
24/11/2017

On 23 November 2017, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) decided that commitment decisions contain indications of an infringement of antitrust rules.

The ECJ rightfully explains that a commitment decision does not validate the company’s conduct under antitrust rules.  It also reminds that they do not prevent national competition authorities or courts from finding that the conduct or agreement concerned violates antitrust rules. 

But, the Court added that national courts are required to take into account the preliminary assessment of the Commission and “to regard it as an indication, if not prima facie evidence, of the anticompetitive nature of the agreement at issue”.   

It is difficult to define the impact of such a judgment. It may, however, give a lot of weight to such a preliminary assessment and its evidentiary value.  As rightfully pointed out by the ECJ,  commitment decisions cannot create a legitimate expectation from the companies that their conduct complies with antitrust rules; but, we would contend that they create the expectation that national courts or agencies are not “required” to regard it as prima facie evidence. 

The decisional nature of commitment decisions should, in our view, be limited to the binding character of the commitments proposed by companies.  Defining  the preliminary assessment as prima facie evidence would conflict with what companies may expect from a commitment process as defined in Regulation 1/2003. 

Judgment of 23 November 2017, Gasorba e.a., C-547/16

Voir aussi : Buyle Legal ( Mr. Bruno Lebrun ,  Ms. Laure Bersou )

[+ http://www.buylelegal.be]

Mr. Bruno Lebrun Mr. Bruno Lebrun
Partner
[email protected]
Ms. Laure Bersou Ms. Laure Bersou
Avocat
[email protected]

Tous les articles Droit Européen

Derniers articles Droit Européen

European Commission unveils its 'Fit for 55' package
23/07/2021

On Wednesday 14 July 2021, the European Commission took a major step to accomplish its ambitious goal of making Europe the...

European Commission unveils its 'Fit for 55' package Read more

Draft revised vertical regulation and guidelines
22/07/2021

The European Commission takes a hard line against online platforms, dual distribution and MFNs

Draft revised vertical regulation and guidelines Read more

EU and US Merger review and privacy law: Does the Google/Fitbit decision draw a line in the sand?
19/07/2021

The interplay between merger enforcement and privacy policy has recently attracted significant attention. The key question...

EU and US Merger review and privacy law: Does the Google/Fitbit decision draw a line in the sand? Read more

General Court of the CJ annuls State aid decision in Amazon case
13/07/2021

The case concerned the arm’s length nature of a royalty paid by a Luxembourg operating company (LuxOpCo) to a L...

General Court of the CJ annuls State aid decision in Amazon case Read more

Derniers articles de Mr. Bruno Lebrun

Derniers articles de Ms. Laure Bersou

LexGO Network