Important decision of the ECJ concerning seconded employees: ability to revoke the E101/ A1 certificate issued by another member state
13/02/2018

On the 6th of February 2018 the European Court of Justice (ECJ) delivered an important judgement concerning the social security-certificate E101/A1. Certificates issued by another Member State can be disregarded if they were fraudulently obtained and the competent authority doesn’t review or withdraw the certificate in the light of these (new) circumstances. This judgement will most definitely have an impact on the legal certainty of these certificates.

It was the Belgian Supreme court who demanded a preliminary ruling upon the E 101-certificates as issued under article 11.1 Regulation no 574/72 in a criminal case between the Belgian Social Security and a Bulgarian construction company-network. More precisely if it would be possible for courts from another Member State than the sending Member State to annul or disregard the certificate if afterwards it has been ascertained that the certificate was obtained fraudulently or based on false assumptions or facts.

A Belgian judicial investigation conducted in Bulgaria established that those Bulgarian undertakings carried out no significant activity in Bulgaria, although an E101/A1 –certificate was issued in Bulgaria. In order to revoke this certificate the Belgian authorities contacted the competent Bulgarian institution. This institution stated that the conditions of posting were, at the time those certificates were issued, met for administrative purposes by the various Bulgarian undertakings in question. The new facts weren’t taken into account and the certificate wasn’t revoked.

The ECJ stated that in these specific circumstances:

  1. Certificates were clearly obtained fraudulently by means of a representation of facts which did not reflect the reality of the situation, with the intention of evading the conditions laid down in EU legislation in respect of the posting of workers. The national court has to investigate the existence of such fraud on the basis of that evidence and with due regard to the safeguards inherent in the right to a fair trial which must be granted to those persons:T
  2. he competent Bulgarian institution, when called upon to review and withdraw the certificates at issue in the main proceedings, in the light of the results of the investigation of the Belgian Inspection, failed to take those results into consideration for the purpose of reviewing the grounds for the issue of those certificates;

The national court of the Member State, to which the workers are posted, may disregard the E 101/A1 certificates and must determine in a fair trial whether the persons suspected of having used posted workers ostensibly covered by certificates obtained fraudulently, may be held liable under the applicable national law.

Even though this decision of the ECJ is only applicable when fraud (objectively and subjectively) is proved, the risk remains in the interpretation of the national courts of the existence of fraud.

Related : Loyens & Loeff CVBA ( Mr. Kris De Schutter ,  Ms. Melissa Claessens )

[+ http://www.loyensloeff.com]

Mr. Kris De Schutter Mr. Kris De Schutter
Partner
kris.de.schutter@loyensloeff.com
Ms. Melissa Claessens Ms. Melissa Claessens
Associate
melissa.claessens@loyensloeff.com

Click here to see the ad(s)
All articles Social Security Law

Lastest articles Social Security Law

Aanpassing van CAO nr. 103 betreffende tijdskrediet
15/03/2018

De Nationale Arbeidsraad (NAR) heeft de CAO nr. 103 tot invoering van een stelsel van tijdskrediet aangepast teneinde een ...

Aanpassing van CAO nr. 103 betreffende tijdskrediet Read more

Geen beroep op economische werkloosheid mogelijk voor werkgever die werk uitbesteedt aan derden
16/02/2018

De wet van 15 januari 2018 houdende diverse bepalingen inzake werk schrijft nu in de Arbeidsovereenkomstenwet in dat het g...

Read more

A1 verklaring kan (enkel) bij fraude opzij geschoven worden
12/02/2018

Zoals verwacht heeft het Hof van Justitie vandaag geoordeeld dat de nationale rechter een A1 formulier buiten toepassing k...

Read more

Réduction des cotisations sociales pour « indépendants starters »
06/02/2018

La Chambre a adopté, ce 25 janvier 2018, un projet de loi permettant aux indépendants « starters&...

Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Kris De Schutter

Holiday accumulation – (no) news under the sun
07/02/2018

Holiday accumulation is the next step for employees to plan their career and work – life balance. Since these provis...

Read more

Guideline ruling commission on proportionate use of warrants
02/02/2018

Belgian ruling commission has just published rulings in which it made explicit in what circumstances the grant of warrants...

Read more

Demotion & older employees who reduce their workload
29/01/2018

On January 25, 2018 a Royal Decree was published, which introduces an exemption from social security contributions for the...

Read more

Belgium Employment & Benefits: Een zomer lang vragen over remuneratie – Case 4
31/07/2017

Recent heeft Lieve beslist om haar woon-werkverkeertraject af te leggen gebruik makend van het openbaar vervoer. Helaas is...

Read more

Lastest articles by Ms. Melissa Claessens

LexGO Network