Settlement in criminal proceedings partially annulled
14/06/2016

Last Thursday (June 2nd) an important decision of the Belgian Constitutional Court partially annulled article 216bis § 2 of the Code of criminal procedure with regard to the settlement and the resulting end of criminal proceedings. The Court stated that article 216bis § 2 violates a set of fundamental rights, including the right to a fair trial and the principle of judicial independence.

The Constitutional Court received four prejudicial questions that were posed by the Chamber of Indictment of the Court of Appeal of Gent in a case regarding suspicious financial transactions. The defendant stated himself being discriminated by the Public Prosecutor, who in application of the articles 216bis and 216ter of the Code of criminal procedure could decide whether or not to grant a settlement, even after criminal proceedings were started and without any judicial verification of the decision’s justification.

The decision of the Constitutional Court stated that §2 of article 216bis violates articles 10 and 11 of the Belgian Constitution, combined with the right to a fair trial and the principle of judicial independence as stated by article 151 of the Constitution, article 6.1 of the European Convention of Human Rights and article 14,1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, as far as it grants the public prosecutor the power to end criminal proceedings that were already initiated or that were already pending before the Courts, by means of settlement, without any actual judicial verification.

The Constitutional Court does not criticize the fact that the Public Prosecutor has the possibility to settle a case that has already been initiated or is already pending before the Courts, but questions arise with the lack of substantive judicial verification. The fact that a judge merely has to verify whether all formal conditions for a settlement are satisfied, is, according to the Constitutional Court, not sufficient. According to the Constitutional Court the judge should be able to properly verify the settlement concluded by the Public Prosecutor, including the proportionality and the opportunity of such settlement.

The annulment of article 216bis §2 will not have any influence on settlements concluded and validated in the past: the decision will not change anything in cases where the settlement has already lead to closure of the criminal proceedings. The Constitutional Court states that the article will remain valid until the decision has been published in the Belgian Official Journal, which could take a few weeks. After the decision has been published, it will be up to Minister of Justice Koen Geens to amend the article and to extend the judicial verification during settlement proceedings.

Related : Stibbe ( Mr. Hans Van Bavel ,  Mr. Dirk Libotte )

[+ http://www.stibbe.com/en/news/2016/june/bru-newsletter-litigation-settlement-in-criminal-proceedings-partially-annulled-uk]

Mr. Hans Van Bavel Mr. Hans Van Bavel
Partner
hans.vanbavel@stibbe.com
Mr. Dirk Libotte Mr. Dirk Libotte
Counsel
dirk.libotte@stibbe.com

Click here to see the ad(s)
All articles General criminal law

Lastest articles General criminal law

Sextorsion ? Comment se prémunir des dangers du cybersex
30/11/2018

Les technologies de l’information et de la communication, dont les réseaux sociaux, ont révolutionn&ea...

Read more

"Speech is silver, silence is golden" – or does the gold belong to the crown witness?
26/09/2018

Belgium has recently seen the role of the crown witness incorporated in the Code of Criminal Procedure through the Act of ...

Read more

La transaction pénale étendue jugée inconstitutionnelle
03/06/2016

Ce 2 juin 2016, la Cour constitutionnelle a rendu un arrêt n° 83/2016 constatant l'inconstitutionnalit&...

Read more

Potpourri II: de wijzigingen in het strafrecht en de strafvordering op een rij
26/02/2016

Op 19 februari werd in het Belgisch Staatsblad het tweede deel van het geplande Potpourri-vierluik van Minister van Justit...

Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Hans Van Bavel

Strafrechtelijke aansprakelijkheid van vennootschappen en leidinggevenden – de lege lata, de lege...
23/06/2017

De strafrechtelijke aansprakelijkheid voor misdrijven gepleegd in het kader van een rechtspersoon is een klassiek thema ui...

Read more

Potpourri II: de wijzigingen in het strafrecht en de strafvordering op een rij
26/02/2016

Op 19 februari werd in het Belgisch Staatsblad het tweede deel van het geplande Potpourri-vierluik van Minister van Justit...

Read more

Lastest articles by Mr. Dirk Libotte

Potpourri II: de wijzigingen in het strafrecht en de strafvordering op een rij
26/02/2016

Op 19 februari werd in het Belgisch Staatsblad het tweede deel van het geplande Potpourri-vierluik van Minister van Justit...

Read more

LexGO Network